Reviews
Reviews
Being a Broad in Japan: book cover
Book Info:
Being a Broad in Japan: Everything a Western woman needs to survive and thrive
By Caroline Pover
Alexandra Press; ISBN: 4990079108; (July 19, 2001), pp. 544.

Women's Resources
 
Being A Broad
World Bank Statistics on women in Japan
Foreign Executive Women
Association for Women in Finance
Digital Eve
Association of Foreign Wives of Japanese
American Fuji


e-mail this page Print this page
Chick Flick
By: Yuki Allyson Honjo

Reading books on life in Japan, one gets the distinct impression that a Westerner making a home in the country is like living in an alternate reality—and all of the realities are different, all of them bizarre. In American Fuji, the American protagonist states, "Expect the unexpected, this is Japan," and changes jobs from a college professor to selling fantasy funerals. In Ameilie Nothomb's semi-autobiographical novel Fear and Trembling, a young Belgian office worker in a Japanese company suffers delicate Satre-esque social tortures and humiliations. Western women, she suggests, need not apply to a Japanese corporation. Even in former Washington Post correspondent T. R. Reid's non-fictional account, Confucius Lives Next Door (1999), Japan is portrayed as having the "safest streets, the best schools, the most stable families in the world." Reid's vision of Japan evokes the wholesome qualities of 1950s US television such as Leave it to Beaver or perhaps The Donna Reed Show—alternate realities indeed. 

In contrast, Caroline Pover's book, Being A Broad in Japan serves as a more balanced, commonsensical reminder to all Westerners that life in Japan has its ups and downs. Living in a foreign country is hard work, and Japan is no exception—a sometimes challenging, sometimes insular, but ultimately a rewarding foreign country.

Which brings us to the point of this review: you can look at Being A Broad in Japan in one of two ways. On the one hand, it is a guide for western women to survive and thrive in Japan. In some ways reading Pover's book is like reading a set of stereo instructions. She offers readers step-by-step instructions from everything from getting a work visa, finding a job, to filing a marriage certificate. While not high literature, it gets the job done: for a new comer in Japan (or even a long-term resident) clear, easy to follow advice is invaluable. In that respect, men, as well as women, would do well to read it. On the other, it is a compendia of women's experiences in Japan. Before embarking on the book, Pover had published a magazine with the same title as the book as a forum for the exchange of information and ideas. After the magazine closed, Pover took advantage of this network, as well as interviewing over 200 women in the course of writing her book: snippets of the women's voices give the book an air of authenticity. They reassure readers that however happy or miserable life in Japan may be, other women shared the same experiences.

...It seems that the thin line between "Japan" and personal experience is blurred in this book—this is neither good nor bad and makes for lively reading...

What's it like to be "a broad" in Japan? Pover does not offer a single view: each experience is unique. Many women feel strong feelings of alienation and isolation. For one thing, some western women perceive the Japanese as "The Other." Many feel a lack of a sense of "belonging" in Japan. One woman writes, "No matter how comfortable you may feel at times here, you will inevitably be reminded that this is not your country. Those messages, no matter how kindly delivered, can be devastating at certain times. Be prepared."

By having a number of first hand accounts, some of the more stronger feelings on life in Japan are shown in within a cycle of adjusting to a foreign culture. For example, she focuses one chapter on pampering and beauty. Pover discusses western women adjusting to ever fashion conscious Japan, and the various assaults on body image when "nothing"-from bras to shoes-ever seems to fit. "I see myself as Amazon Woman here, although back home I'm pretty average." "When I sat down on a train, I felt that people were making extra space for my 'enormous' (36 inch) hips. . .My feelings about my appearance grew out of a profound sense of not fitting in, and not belonging." This is all perfectly normal, Pover assures us."Regardless of their ideas of 'femminity,' most Western women go through a phase of feeling big, clumsy, and unattractive." These feelings abate over time, she assures us, gives the reader ideas for short term "fixes" such as pamper and massages to ease the process.

As an all-embracing document on foreign women in Japan, therein lies the book's greatest asset and liability. Pover's resistance to typifying life in Japan sometimes works to great advantage—as life in any major city in the world has its saints, sinners, and the occasional whacko walking the streets, a metropolis such as Tokyo is no exception. A seemingly obvious observation, but within the context of the relentless mythology that Japan is somehow different (as typified by Nihonjinron) or "unique," it is a sharp observation.

However, because Pover equally validates all the experiences of the women in the book, it is difficult for the reader to assess whether the anecdotes are representative. For example, in a section on jobs, she has 85 pages of first hand accounts of working in Japan. Besides the perhaps more usual JET program English teacher, she interviewed almost everyone from an Ivy league educated stripper, a financial planner, a nurse, to a freelance illustrator. While interesting in voyueristic way, such broad survey of jobs held by women with an even wider variety of backgrounds and abilities, is not ultimately useful. 

It seems that the thin line between "Japan" and personal experience is blurred in this book—this is neither good nor bad and makes for lively reading. However, it begs the question, At what point can certain experiences be ascribed as typical of that country? In a section on mental health, she writes of the stresses of living in a country which is, at times, sexist and sometimes baffling, even to a fluent Japanese speaker. As a sojourner in Japan, it is easy to fall into the trap of ascribing a rude encounter, a date who was a jerk, a sexist remark, racism, homophobia, a psychotic boss, or even something as benign as a misunderstanding—the sandpaper (or sandblaster) of life—as endemic of the country as a whole, not to individuals. Where is that line? When is a bad day merely a bad day, or a symptom of a pervasive attitude? Pover never really answers the question, but in reporting the wealth of experiences of her interviewees, she avoids pat condemnations of "Japan" as a nation or a culture.

The above comments are more food for thought rather than criticisms of Pover's book—as a guide book, it is excellent: packed with information on coping with life in general, not just in Japan, it is clear, lucid, and above all, useful. Male or female, young or old, straight or gay, if you are new to, or considering moving to Japan, it is essential reading. At the very least, it is a book to be kept stashed at the bottom of your bag. It contains phone numbers and resources from everything from English speaking gynecologists to organic food delivery services. If you don't speak Japanese, each section has useful phrases in Roman letters. Buy it now, you'll be glad to have it when you have an emergency such as an earthquake, or when the earth stops moving, a pregnancy. Most of all, the book's attitude is perhaps the most valuable—life in Japan, like life in general, is what you make of it. Common sense? Perhaps, but an observation that many more learned writers on Japan have missed.


© Copyright 2002-2005 JapanReview.Net, All rights reserved.
Essays
Interviews
Letters
About this site
About us
Newsletter
Contact us
Home
Search this site